ESPE Abstracts (2015) 84 P-2-477

BASIC: Bone Age Study in Children

Toby Cockilla, Amanda Hewittb, Neil Wrightb & Charlotte Eldera,b


aSheffield University, Sheffield, UK; bSheffield CHildren’s Hospital, Sheffield, UK


Background: Bone age studies require X-ray of the left hand and wrist to assess skeletal maturity. The Tanner-Whitehouse 3 (TW3) scoring method provides an objective framework for calculating bone age and specifies exact placement of the hand. In our service we have noted a number of poor quality films, caused by difficulty with hand placement, e.g. scrunching of the fingers. This compromises the ability to score accurately and in a proportion necessitates re-X-ray, with time, financial and radiation exposure consequences.

Aim: To assess X-ray quality and need for re-X-ray in patients having TW3 bone ages.

Method: We performed a prospective study of all bone age X-rays conducted at Sheffield Children’s Hospital from May 2013 to February 2014. The quality of bone age X-rays was rated by a single specialist auxology nurse. The position of the thumb, fingers and the overall clarity of the X-ray were scored on a simple 1–3 scale (poor, adequate, good), generating a score out of 9. The need for re-X-ray was noted.

Results: Of the 259 bone ages studied, from patients aged 1.92 to 18.48 years, 123 were females. There were 12 X-rays scoring 1 (4.6%) (poor quality) for both the finger and thumb positions and 9 for X-ray clarity (3.5%). The number of studies scoring less than 3 for position of fingers, thumb and overall clarity was 38 (14.7%), 26 (10.0%) and 77 (29.7%) respectively. The number of re-X-rays required was 28 (10.8%).

Discussion: We have shown that achieving good quality films on which to assess bone age may be more difficult than presumed. We believe the re-X-ray rate to be unnecessarily high and have devised a simple hand outline template, placed on the X-ray plate, to encourage the correct positioning of the hand. We are currently evaluating its efficacy using the same scoring system.

Article tools

My recent searches

No recent searches.

My recently viewed abstracts